Putting a Human Face on the Immigration Debate

Happy Thanksgiving

Happy Thanksgiving. (Photo: Dracobontanicus)

As families around the country settle into the mood for the most American holiday of the year, it seems appropriate to reflect on the question of who Americans are now, at Thanksgiving 2010.

A quick look around reveals that we are still a nation of immigrants, just as we were back in the 17th century when the Pilgrims were starving through their first winter.

But the personal stories of today’s immigrants are all too often lost amid the bickering over immigration reform. For that reason, a Center for Community Change project called “We Are America” is trying to bring the main characters in these stories to the forefront. The project is an Internet-based audio visual story bank of immigrant profiles, open to the public. You can search for stories using words like “undocumented,” “DREAM Act,” “deportations,” or “Arizona” and meet individuals directly connected to those issues and places.

“The idea behind this project was to bring back the human element, the human side of the debate around immigration, and not just to talk about those bad things, and how people are affected adversely, but also to lift up the positive, and feature some of the stories of immigrants and how they’re really revitalizing their communities,” Burke Stansbury, the project coordinator at the Center for Community Change, told WBAI Radio in July.

The project also directly connects journalists with individuals featured on the website, so that their stories can be disseminated further. In a way, you could call it “citizen journalism,” though the majority of these pieces are professionally produced. “We Are America” is the immigrant niche within a growing field of open-source story-gathering projects, like American Public Media’s Public Insight Network, which seeks to build a network of hundreds of thousands of sources (regular people) who public radio and online journalists can tap as needed.

It’s all an effort to better understand the people who make up America, and reveal their stories, personalities and opinions to a wider audience. While this is an important moment to watch congressional chess moves on immigration legislation, especially the DREAM Act, what happens on the ground to individual immigrants, seems just as interesting, and often more meaningful.

    Tagged as: , , ,

    • Joel Wischkaemper

      A quick look around reveals that we are still a nation of immigrants, just as we were back in the 17th century
      =================================
      Not even close. In fact, everyone had better take a far more intensive look at our country and avoid anyone who cannot realize what has changed, and how it has changed.

      We have far, far more people. Most of them are Citizens as in Citizen Soldiers, and an ugly dose of illegal aliens who have come demanding everything they can. They are illegal, and while some work, other don’t, and using excellent forged documents, collect a great deal of welfare. Pass the Real I.D. Act with the law enforcement tools, and none of this would have happened. But it did, and those illegal aliens are the most expensive workers in the world. Mexico, watching the foolishness of it all, delays yet again the process of reforming their country and taking care of their people. And so it is that this thanksgiving that we have to take care of the Citizens of Mexico because the Corruption in Mexico is STILL running the country compliments of the American Political System. I cannot compete with the number of words up there and so, I offer excellent web sites that have been involved in immigration research and Congressional Testimony. Please.. read them, and make our next Thanksgiving one for the people of the United States, and all who would join us, legally.
      http://www.fairus.org
      http://www.cis.org
      http://www.numbersusa.com
      Immigration Counter
      http://immigrationcounters.com/
      http://www.politico.com/static/PPM170_101122_dreamalert.html

    • Commonsense78

      FLASH NEWS FOR YOU: To get welfare you have to PROVE you are leally here in this Country, forged documents won’t get you anywhere, if UNDOCUMENTED people get any help is because of their US CITIZEN child(ren) and that ONLY goes to assist the kid(s) not the adult because they do not qualify, SO PLEASE don’t confuse people. Do a little research before posting that way your comment makes sense and people don’t think less of you. HAPPY HOLIDAY

    • TheTruth

      Actually, it’s illegal for Social Services to report you as an illegal immigrant to Immigration bc it’s considered discrimination. You don’t have to be a legal citizen to get a SS# and a Driver’s License, you just have to prove where you live, which just takes some mail coming to an address. Which is all you need to get TCA (Temporary Cash Assistance), Food Stamps, Gas & Electric Assistance, Rental Assistance (Section 8), free college education, etc. Based on information showed to me by illegal immigrants I know. One department of government is not allowed to report to another department discrepancies in Legal Citizenship status, it’s discrimination, thanks to ACORN and other shady immigration proponent organizations. That being said, I’m all for people coming over LEGALLY, just like I did.

    • Ironweed

      News flash for YOU: Illegal immigrants cost American citizens an excess of $100 Billion annually. About $57 million of that is to educate their children. The remainder gets divided between prenatal care, WIC services, food stamps and section 8 housing for our new little citizens.

    • dt

      Flash to you common sense. Illegals do get welfare. All they have to do is reside in the sanctuary state or just use 1 of the millions of anchors that we pay for. The states administer all welfare programs and some states are much easier than others for illegals to get benefits. If you have any doubt remember obama’s own aunt was getting benefits.

    • Pingback: On Thanksgiving: An introductory reflection on immigration, the DREAM Act, and migrant education

    • sg

      To summarize, what your saying is—– Why don’t we just put on our white hooded robes and round up all of the illegal aliens and show’em who’s in charge! Ya know, like we showed the black folks a few years back….. Damn Mexicans, come over here and pick tomatoes and then have the audacity to want to eat them in the same restaurants we eat at. To hell with that! I”ll not lower myself to set down with a servent, I mean illegal alien.

      You people are pathetic. Get your head out of your ass and move forward.