A Countdown to Reform, Despite Conflicting Reports on Immigration Bill’s Status

Rally outside Sen. Charles Schumer's Manhattan Office

Rally outside Sen. Charles Schumer's Manhattan Office. (Photo: NYIC)

Advocates across the nation have begun a 10 day countdown for immigration reform that will culminate on May 1st. May Day has become a traditional day to advocate for immigrant rights, and this year, hundreds of rallies and marches are scheduled to be held across the country.

In New York, immigrant community leaders gathered outside Senator Charles Schumer’s  (D-NY) office yesterday, who has worked with Senator Lindsay Graham (R-SC) on a bipartisan bill for immigration reform.

“Every day, we’ll be taking action to remind Senator Schumer that he must follow through on his commitment to deliver a strong, bipartisan immigration reform bill,” said Chung-Wha Hong, executive director of the New York Immigration Coalition, in a press release.

In the same release, Ali Noorani, executive director of the National Immigration Forum and chair of the Reform Immigration FOR America campaign was quoted as saying, “Senator Schumer took on this responsibility, and he needs to deliver. We know the task is difficult and that Republicans have not stepped up as strong bipartisan partners, but we need leadership. We can not afford more delay.”

But the status of Schumer’s bill, and the likelihood of Congress taking on immigration reform as its next major agenda item, is looking very murky.

On April 10th, House Majority Leader Harry Reid spoke to thousands at a rally in Las Vegas, promising that congress would pass immigration reform asap. “We need to do this this year. We can’t let excuses like a Supreme Court nomination get in the way,” he said.

But three days later, he flip flopped, saying “We won’t get to immigration reform this work period.” (The current congressional work period ends just before Memorial day.)

Rally outside Sen. Charles Schumer's Manhattan Office

Rally outside Sen. Charles Schumer's Manhattan Office. (Photo: NYIC)

Senator Lindsay Graham also recently expressed doubts the nation would see immigration reform this year, even though he had appeared publicly with Senator Schumer to promote his commitment to it.

“If you’re a red state Democrat, you want to get into an immigration debate right now? I don’t think so,” Graham said.

Yet the Wall Street Journal is reporting that President Obama called Senator Scott Brown (R-MA) on Tuesday to tell him Democrats are moving ahead with immigration reform next month.

“I have an open mind to read the bill,” Brown said. “That doesn’t mean that I will vote for granting amnesty to anyone. But I want to be respectful to the president and to any member who brings me a proposal.”

In his campaign, Obama said he would take up immigration reform during his first year in office. That didn’t happen, and he is being criticized for not making it a priority.

“Latino and immigrant voters remember the promises they heard and are tuned in enough to see they haven’t been kept,” said U.S. Rep. Luis V. Gutierrez (D-IL) in a statement on Tuesday.

A close look at mainstream media and the blogosphere reveals nothing but conflicting reports.

In an article yesterday, L.A. Times reporter Peter Nicholas wrote,  “a White House commitment to overhaul the nation’s immigration system this year is collapsing.”

Yet on the same day, Reuters reported they heard from Congressional aides that Congress may take up an immigration bill next, before a climate bill.

The only thing clear is that immigration reform activists aren’t giving up. They are furious about SB 1070, approved by the Arizona state legislature this week, which grants local and state police sweeping powers to arrest undocumented migrants.

In her statement directed at Sen. Schumer, Chung-Wha Hong, executive director of the New York Immigration Coalition was adamant.

“Too many lives have been lost; and too many families have been ripped apart, for it all to lead to nothing. We need to deliver change. Now!” said Hong.

    Tagged as: , , , , , ,

    • Stan

      A poll from the well-respected Rasmussen firm released yesterday shows that 70% of Arizona voters support the common sense legislation known as SB 1070. Credible polling also shows that nearly 70% of American voters support border enforcement and NOT legalization/amnesty.

      With the southern border still wide open, violence and murder spilling over into our country, with the DHS Inspector General saying his agency could not properly handle millions of amnesty applications — and with our nation’s unemployment rate hovering around 10% — it is incredibly irresponsible and premature of Obama, Reid and Schumer to be pushing “comprehensive immigration reform” a/k/a mass amnesty.

      Sadly but predictably, it appears that the Democratic Party leadership believes that Harry Reid’s dimming reelection prospects trumps common sense, and they will peddle amnesty instead of climate change and the protection of unemployed American citizens and workers.

      American citizens of all ethnic and racial backgrounds have awakened and will not accept the irresponsible and divisive legislation that Charles Schumer has unveiled. The cheap labor and ethnocentric special interests are vocal and have a lot of money, but they do NOT have the support of the American people.

      NO AMNESTY — ENFORCE CURRENT LAWS.

    • Tony Fang

      I felt that all this doesn’t really reflect America as a land of Immigrant, when I was in High School they used to teach me in US history class about how they used to treat all those European Immigrant differently just because they just came from their country without knowing english language what so ever, but when you think about it , all this people over here, their great great grand father was an Immigrant too, and they struggling the first time they came over here to this country, and all of a sudden all this people said that Immigrants will cause America bankruptcy ,” IF America Bankrupt it means the whole world will went bankrupt too”, There is no way this country could go bankrupt, its just Impossible , we far more advance on everything.

    • Pingback: Immigrant Mothers In Arizona: Some Vow to Stay Despite New Law, Others Consider Moving | Feet in 2 Worlds · Immigration news · Immigration reform · Immigrant communities