Immigrant Detained in Raid Sues Arizona Sheriff Arpaio’s Office for Mistreatment

Shortly after her release, Celia Alvarez reads from a journal she kept to document the mistreatment she says she suffered while in custody - Photos: Valeria Fernández.

Shortly after her release, Celia Alvarez reads from a journal she kept to document the mistreatment she says she suffered while in custody. (Photos: Valeria Fernández)

PHOENIX, Arizona – Celia Alejandra Alvarez, a former undocumented worker detained in a workplace raid, is accusing the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office of negligence and mistreatment in a federal lawsuit. The lawsuit joins a long list of legal actions against Sheriff Joe Arpaio –currently under a criminal grand jury investigation for abuse of power– and comes less than a week after he defiantly announced he will train 881 of his deputies to enforce immigration laws.

Alvarez’s attorneys filed the case before the U.S. District Court of Arizona on February 11. That was exactly a year after she was arrested with 60 co-workers at landscaping contractor Handyman Maintenance Inc. (HMI) for working with false documents.

“I’m not interested in the money I could get out of this,” Alvarez, 32, told Feet in 2 Worlds. “What I want is to denounce the abuse, cruelty and inhumanity of the way in which we are treated by Arpaio.”

In the lawsuit, Alvarez alleges deputies wearing ski masks found her hiding, “lifted her off her feet, and slammed her face into a wall,” causing her injuries on her face, jaw and teeth. A deputy allegedly hit her hard with a clipboard for trying to speak to another detainee. During the three months she spent in detention, Alvarez claims that she didn’t receive proper medical treatment or medicine for the resulting pain.

“He is going to go after more people and that is why we can’t remain silent,” she said. “He should train his deputies so they know they are not supposed to mistreat people.”

Arpaio’s recent decision to escalate his immigration crackdown –his deputies arrested 35 people Tuesday– has become the target of criticism by legal scholars that argue he is operating outside the scope of the law in trying to play the role of the federal government.

In October, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) revoked part of the agreement –known as 287 (g) for the legal provision that permits it– that allowed 160 Maricopa County deputies to enforce immigration laws. But the sheriff has remained defiant ever since.

“We are going to continue our enforcement,” he said during a recent press conference. “My deputies can enforce the illegal immigration laws without the 287 (g) agreement.”

Arpaio also claims he can continue to use Arizona state laws to go after workers, which is what happened in Alvarez’s case.

The HMI sweep was part of Arpaio’s controversial enforcement of Arizona’s employer sanctions law.

The State Legislature passed that law to investigate companies that knowingly hire undocumented labor. But the Sheriff’s and Maricopa County Attorney’s offices have used it to arrest workers on criminal charges of identity theft for using false documents to work.

Alvarez with her youngest son, Daniel, during a march in August for the children of migrants detained during Arpaio's raids.

Alvarez with her youngest son, Daniel, during a march in August for the children of migrants detained during Arpaio's raids.

Alvarez, the mother of four U.S. citizens, worked under the false name of Francisca Perez Mendoza. She worked for three years at HMI, picking up trash for $6 an hour. The company had a contract with Maricopa County for over ten years: some of the services it provided included landscaping at county buildings, including Arpaio’s jails.

Through her cleaning job, Alvarez became familiar with the outside of the Estrella jail for women. She never expected that one day she would find herself inside its walls.

She describes the experience both as traumatic and humiliating.

She said on arrival she was forced to strip in front of male guards. She had to take off the garments she wore as a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints to put on the black and white stripes uniform used in the jail.

Alvarez regrets that she was separated from Daniel, her youngest son, who was three months old and breastfeeding at the time of her arrest.

“What happened marked me for a lifetime,” she said, “but it also hurt my children.”

Claims of mistreatment and negligence by the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office have resulted in over $40 million in settlements and legal fees to victims and families, according to county records.

Another lawsuit filed last week by Armando Nido, a U.S. citizen, alleges sheriff deputies ran him over with a patrol vehicle during a traffic stop outside his home.

Arpaio’s office didn’t return calls regarding the recent lawsuits.

This is the second time the agency is sued in connection to the HMI raid. Last August, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) filed a lawsuit claiming that Julian Mora, 66, a permanent legal resident, and his son Julio, 19, had been improperly detained.

They both were driving towards the company, where Julian worked, when vehicles from the sheriff’s office cut them off 100 yards from HMI. The deputies zip-tied them and transported them to the site and made them wait for three hours, according to the lawsuit. They were not allowed to use the restroom.

ACLU has also sued Arpaio on behalf of U.S. citizens and a tourist who alleged they were racially profiled. Last week, a federal judge imposed sanctions on Arpaio’s office for destroying evidence in connection with this lawsuit.

Many things have changed in Alvarez’s life since the raid on HMI a year ago. On September, she pleaded guilty to one count of criminal impersonation of a legal worker. She was able to obtain a work permit as she fights a process to remove her from the country.

Now she works as an assistant nurse caring for an elder woman.

“It’s hard for me to forget that dark day in which I was arrested,” she said. “Many things have changed in my life, I really can’t stand the sight of seeing the sheriff’s patrols, but this also has opened the doors to a new life.”

    Tagged as: , , , , , ,

    • bernard Schlot

      Arizona is paying dearly for their hate and ignorance. Arpaio’s self-promoting public relation campaign is devastating the economy of the county. Just in legal fees,and pain suffering-awarded to those who were victimized by this clown will increase taxes. You better think twice before electing Hayworth.

    • Pingback: Immigrant Detained in Raid Sues Arizona Sheriff Arpaio’s Office for Mistreatment « Craig Considine

    • Horace Rumphole

      I don’t put much stock in these tales, as contrary to the plaintiffs assertions, she’s out for the money and supported by advocates who have been telling lies about Joe. This too is just a nuisance suit. I hope they hit her with court costs. This is just one more ACLU-pro illegal alien tactic.

    • Delaware Bob

      It’s just one thing after another with these illegal aliens. One thing after another! They know they are here ILLEGALLY and when arrested they sue. When is all this going to stop? I’ll tell you when it’s going to stop. It’s going to stop when we get ALL the illegal aliens out of this Country and back with their families in their own country where they belong.

      Our Federal Government and homeland Security have left us down big time. Why are they not ENFOCING the law? I don’t think Janet Flintstone has a clue on what to do to enforce the law. OK, they are going after the employers. What about the illegal aliens working the jobs? Why aren’t they arrested, their family rounded up and all deported?

      If our Federal Government would get E-Verify in ALL businesses and check ALL employees, we could get the illegal aliens out of those jobs and put an American in the job. Put E-Verify in ALL Social Services including schools, and get the ALL the illegal aliens off these programs they are NOT entitled to.

      I for one am sick and tired of these illegal aliens snubbing their nose at our laws. GET RID OF THEM!

      It’s time for ZERO TOLERENCE with these illegal aliens. It’s time for them get out of this Country and back in their own Country where they belong. When we get rid of the illegal aliens, we will get rid of all the problems that go with them. THAT IS A FACT!

      I’m from Delaware, and we are pressing to get the Oklahoma State Illegal Immigration Law, HB 1804. passed here in Delaware. Three years ago we had about 32,000 illegal aliens here. Today we have about 68,000 illegal aliens here. We have had it! We want our State back!

      You GO, ARIZONA! You are leading the way to get our Country back from this INVASION of the ILLEGAL ALIENS!

    • Pingback: Immigrant Detained in Raid Sues Arizona Sheriff Arpaio’s Office for Mistreatment « Immigration Detention in Arizona

    • To The Republic

      The man is doing his job… He has taken an oath to defend the laws of the state and to protect the Constitution. I would love for someone reading this, who has the know-how, to try and find if this woman ever filed for a tax return under this fraudulent name. Has she ever used insurance benefits or filed a prescription under this fake name..?

      I sure hope that politicians seeking reelection are being forced to choose what side of the fence they are on in this one.

    • amber dru

      I married a foriegn national who was in the U.S. legally and have legal foriegn friends.

      It is so insulting when illegal alien advocates use “immigrants” to try to disguise the difference in their legal status.

      They have no right to break the law.

      The racism/xenophob/nazi/… comparisons won’t work either- I’m not white.

      Blacks don’t see enforcing immigration laws as being equivalent to fighting against slavery or jim crow.

      I don’t know any Jews who think deporting illegal aliens is equivalent to Nazi death camps.

      Here’s a clip of a white woman telling blacks wanting jobs for Americans first is like the KKK.

      http://www.numbersusa.com/content/resources/video/news/anti-amnesty-black-group-called-klan.html?jid=380744&lid=9&rid=3164&tid=412235

      http://www.numbersusa.com/content/resources/video/news/anti-amnesty-black-group-called-klan.html

      Testimony of Barbara Jordan
      Chair, U.S. Commission on Immigration Reform
      Before the U.S. House of Representatives
      Committee on Appropriations
      Subcommittee on Appropriations for the Departments of
      Commerce, Justice, State, the Judiciary and Related Agencies
      March 29, 1995

      She said:Credibility in immigration policy can be summed up in one sentence: those who should get in, get in; those who should be kept out, are kept out; and those who should not be here will be required to leave.

      The head of the NAACP also disagrees with ANOTHER amnesty.

      http://www.youtube.com/watch

    • http://www.antiagingreference.com Lillian King

      Public Relations is all about pleasing the common people.-:’

    • Pingback: Justice Department Sues Country’s “Toughest Sheriff” Joe Arpaio | Feet in 2 Worlds · Immigration news · Immigration reform · Immigrant communities

    • http://www.lunch-bags.net John Ali

      you should always maintain good public relations specially if you operate a business:~,