Arizona Sheriff Defiant as Debate Over Local Immigration Enforcement Program Intensifies

PHOENIX, Arizona – A proposed agreement, scheduled to be voted on today by the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors, may offer a glimpse of the federal government’s plans to modify a widely criticized program that authorizes local police to enforce U.S. immigration laws.

Sheriff Joe Arpaio speaks to the press in Phoenix as Maricopa County Attorney Andrew Thomas looks on.  Photo: Valeria Fernandez

Sheriff Joe Arpaio speaks to the press in Phoenix as Maricopa County Attorney Andrew Thomas looks on. Photo: Valeria Fernandez

The Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office has the largest force in the nation authorized under the 287(g) program. Under the existing agreement sheriff’s deputies were able to question people about their immigration status during traffic stops and other types of police investigations. The new contract limits deputies under the command of Sheriff Joe Arpaio to identify undocumented immigrants only within the county jails.

Recently, the Southwest Border Taskforce, an advisory group set up by Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano, recommended that the 287(g) program be scaled back, limiting its use to identifying undocumented migrants in jails.

In July, Napolitano announced a review of all 287(g) agreements across the nation. The new contracts would focus on the apprehension of immigrants with a criminal record, she said.

The Department of Homeland Security gave all 66 participating agencies a 90-day-period to review the new contracts and sign them. But DHS hasn’t confirmed whether it will continue working with Arpaio in any fashion.

“We’re still in the signing window process,” said Vincent Picard a spokesperson for Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). “No final decisions have been made.”

DHS has until October 14th –the end of the 90 day review period- to decide whether Arpaio will retain any immigration powers at all. But that hasn’t stopped the sheriff or his critics from renewing their war of words over the treatment of undocumented immigrants.

“They just don’t want this sheriff to investigate and arrest illegal aliens,” said Arpaio during a press conference yesterday.

Arpaio, who has signed the proposed new agreement, also announced he’ll conduct an immigration sweep in two weeks even if he doesn’t have federal powers. The sheriff added that he’ll drive undocumented immigrants to the U.S.-Mexico border if necessary to aid in their deportation.

“I’m going to continue doing everything I’ve been doing. Now I’m free of the federal government,” he said.

Arpaio can still use the state employer sanctions and identity theft laws to conduct raids at workplaces. A state human smuggling law has allowed him to incarcerate migrants who hire smugglers to cross the border.

The proposed agreement may represent an unwelcome change for Arpaio’s agency. But pro-immigrant groups, locally and nationally, argue that the 287(g) program doesn’t need to be mended, it needs to be terminated.

“If DHS continues its relationship with Joe Arpaio, it is making a historic mistake by lending the full force and legitimacy of the federal government to a rogue cop certain to go down in history as a serial violator of civil rights and an enemy of the Latino community,” said Frank Sharry, Executive Director of America’s Voice a pro-immigrant organization in Washignton D.C in a press release issued Tuesday.

Carlos Garcia a member of the PUENTE movement, a pro-immigrant group, argued that the proposed new agreement is not a victory for immigrants. “Most of the people that get deported are deported because other police departments bring them to Arpaio’s jails,” said Garcia, referring to migrants accused of carrying a false driver license or other false documents. Garcia said Arpaio can still use his power to detain people for minor offenses and bring them to the jail if he suspects they’re undocumented.

With a majority of Republicans, the single Democrat on the Board of Supervisors is Mary Rose Wilcox who has been critical of Arpaio’s immigration crackdown.

“I cannot support it,” said Wilcox who anticipated she will vote against it. “It has been an open door for the abuses of the Latino community.”

Wilcox said she would rather wait for the outcome of a U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) investigation into Arpaio’s practices after allegations of civil rights violations come to light.

The supervisor also stated that there have been a number of lawsuits against the county because of Arpaio’s misuse of his 287(g) powers targeting U.S. citizens. She said she is concerned about the cost of future lawsuits.

On September 28th, the Congressional Hispanic Caucus (CHC) sent a letter to President Obama calling for the termination of all 287(g) programs across the country.

“The misuse of the 287(g) program by its current participants has rendered it ineffective and dangerous to community safety,” reads the letter. The document was signed by congresswoman Nydia Velázquez (D-New York), chair of CHC and congressman Luis V. Gutiérrez (D-Illinois)

“Although its stated purpose is to provide law enforcement a tool to pursue criminals, it is our experience that state and local law enforcement officials actually use their expanded and often unchecked powers under the program to target immigrants and persons of color.”

Secretary Napolitano has been a long time supporter of the use of 287(g) programs in jails and prisons. While she was governor of Arizona the state prisons signed an agreement with the federal government. The memorandum allowed jailers to determine the immigration status of prisoners before their release and turn them over to Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) custody.

    Tagged as: , , , , , ,

    • Stacy

      Not only did she sign a program to ensure that the AZ state prisons use 287(g) to check inmates’ status but she helped Arpaio attain his 287(g).

      What alot of people don’t know is that Arpaio was initially DENIED by ICE to sign on to the program, and it wasn’t until Napolitano’s intervention that she was able to help broker this deal.

      ICE already knew what we all know – that Arpaio was a one sandwich short of a picnic and that’s probably why he was initially denied.

      Napolitano positioned herself as tough on border issues to get re-elected in right-wing AZ and then then her appointment.

      If Obama doesn’t pull the reigns on Apraio and Napolitano it will come back as the biggest mistake he makes.

      He’s already losing credibility with the Latinos that voted him into office on the promise of immigration reform.

      This administration has to make some serious decisions.

    • DeportAllillegals

      Sheriff Joe is Enforcing the law!! I am so sick of some Latinos identifying themselves in terms on Illegal Immigration. This is not a racial issue, as much as you would like to make it one, it is a legal issue. The reason Arpaio is arresting so many Latino compare to other races is because of the proximity of Arizona to the Mexican border and the fact that the illegtal alien population in Arizona are predominantly from Mexico. I dont think there are too many illegal Irish people in Arizona for him to arrest. Let’s be realistic about this and stop turning it into a racial issue.

    • brittanicus

      This Sheriff doesn’t pander for campaign contributions from the business communities? So because he doesn’t comply with their demands, as they do, they desire him out of office? He is an ongoing danger and worst nightmare to the corporate agenda for illegal discount workers. Now he has a free hand to arrest and not no longer restrained by 287 G federal law, but can use the powers of state laws detain illegal aliens and the criminal elements amongst them. We need more Joe’s tent cities and his inmate cuisine of bologna sandwiches, since being subjected to this type of incarceration will deter the most ardent inmate? Nationwide we need more inflexible officers of the law, who will not prostrate to the open border lunatics? Not the soft hands of manipulated cops who don’t make waves, as they are contemplating looking towards an easy road to retirement.

      However the corrupt lawmakers around the nation, have not been able to undermine E-Verify? AS YET? YES! Legal Immigration matters? We should announce to the world that newcomers are welcome, if they come through the front door? We only need those immigrants with specialized skills, such as computer engineers, scientists, doctors and those with highly recommended credentials as developed nations? America has a sovereign right who we choose to settle here? What we don’t need is pregnant women slipping across our border, for instant citizenship of their child or destitute illegal aliens whose cannot exist without taxpayer welfare, chain family migration? We don’t need in these country illegal recipients who need free health care, education when we already ignore our own people who live in poverty? We need to enforce the 1986 immigration reform law (IRCA), not cripple it for the sake of parasite businesses that live of the slavery of millions of foreign national workers. Seeing that the business world are screaming for more Guest Workers, they should take on the responsibility of paying for their health care and education, instead of dropping sick illegal labor of at the emergency room. to, leave the hospital bill for taxpayers. Instead of expecting the American people to pay for the enormous burden, they should pay separate expenditures for every illegal foreign national and their families.

      We need to execute now, a complete war immigration chest containing mandated E-Verify for every worker–NOT REPRESSED–, or 287 G, local police arrest of foreign workers, the Rep.Duncan Hunter original national fence, instead of chopping it down to single line. We need enforcement of our laws, with harsh penalties for violating them. We need politicians we can trust, instead of those elected such as Sen.Reid, Speaker Pelosi, Feinstein and a whole list, who can be graded as Anti-American worker, anti-sovereignty, pro-illegal immigration and compromiser’s of the Rule of Law. Submerge them in your anger and frustration at 202-224-3121 Find out the buried truth at NUMBERSUSA, JUDICIAL WATCH & CAPSWEB, for overpopulation facts.

    • Pingback: Raid Expected in Phoenix Raises Questions About Local Enforcement of Immigration Laws « Feet In 2 Worlds, Immigration News

    • http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robinson_v._California Andrew

      “DeportAllIllegals” I am curious how you can tell Latinos this issue is not about race. I suspect you are not Latino. In addition, it is not a criminal offense to be an illegal alien.

      http://www.wnd.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=57266

      and also

      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robinson_v._California

      Arresting people without probable cause might seem ok because to you these people have no right to be here, but using your logic a police officer can arrest you because he thinks you may have an unlicensed firearm because you look and sound like a redneck.

    • Pingback: Pro-Immigrant Demonstrators and Hispanic Media Confront Sheriff Arpaio on Visit to Southern California « Feet In 2 Worlds, Immigration News

    • Pingback: The Year in Review: Arizona Immigrants Face New Year With Old Fears | Feet in 2 Worlds, immigration news

    • Pingback: Pro-Immigrant Protesters and Hispanic Media Confront Sheriff Arpaio in Southern California | Feet in 2 Worlds, immigration news

    • Pingback: Raid Expected in Phoenix Raises Questions About Local Enforcement of Immigration Laws | Feet in 2 Worlds, immigration news