Immigrant Family Torn Apart in Arizona Raid

Sheriff Arpaio has arrested 248 immigrants in raids allegedly aimed at unlawful hiring, but no employer has been penalized.

PHOENIX, Arizona — Katherine Figueroa was playing outside her home Saturday morning when she overheard the news coming from a nearby TV. The Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office had just raided the car wash where her father and mother worked.

She rushed to see her dad’s image on television. His expression looked worried, his hands were tied with plastic cuffs.

Her eyes filled with tears, the 9-year-old made a plea to President Barack Obama to return her parents home in a video produced by Arizona activists and reports on the Univision network.

“I want my parents back, is not fair for me to be alone,” said Katherine who was born in the U.S. and is a U. S. citizen.

Katherine Figueroa saw her father's immigration arrest on TV. (Photo: Valeria Fernández)

Katherine Figueroa saw her father's immigration arrest on TV. (Photos: Valeria Fernández)

Listen to Katherine in an interview with Feet in 2 Worlds:

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

Although the federal government has announced changes to its policies regarding work-site immigration raids, not much has changed in the Phoenix area, where Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio is implementing what critics call “his own brand of law.”

“The message I have for everybody is that we’re going to continue to arrest those that violate the ID theft laws, but also if they’re illegal,” said Arpaio during a press conference outside the car wash on Saturday.

The owner of the Lindstrom Family Auto Wash did not respond to an interview request.

The arrest of 14 workers in the small business in central Phoenix is the seventh raid to take place since Arpaio started enforcing a new state law aimed at cracking down on employers who knowingly hire undocumented labor. Over all, at least 248 workers have been arrested and most of them face identity theft charges for working with fake documents.

But no employer has been penalized. The state law includes suspension of a business license at the first offense and revocation of the license if they are caught again.

The consequences for workers are life changing. Family separation and deportation with a felony on their record are the norm.

On Monday, Katherine’s mother Sandra Figueroa, 33, cried inside the Estrella Jail visitation room, worried about her daughter’s well-being and her own future.

“We were just making a living, we weren’t committing any crimes,” said Figueroa, the only woman arrested during the raid. She had worked at the car wash for nine years, her husband Carlos for eleven.

The morning of the raid she was vacuuming a car when Carlos came rushing to tell her she needed to hide. But deputies had circled the premises and found her shortly after.

“I never thought the sheriff would raid our workplace,” she said, adding officers were rude and constantly yelled at those arrested, almost running a worker over with one of their vehicles.

Figueroa remembers that two days before the sweep, two Hispanic men came with cars that had small stickers from the sheriff’s office.

“Maybe they where coming to investigate,” she said.

Katherine with her grandmother Mercedes Hernández (Photo: Valeria Fernández)

Katherine with her grandmother Mercedes Hernández.

For undocumented relatives of those arrested the raid creates another obstacle because they’re not allowed to visit their detained relatives.

Arpaio’s policies prohibit undocumented people from entering his jails.

The Figueroas’ relatives are desperate and heartbroken.

“They’re catching people like birds in their nest, which are the workplaces. That’s the truth,” said Mercedes Hernández, Katherine’s maternal grandmother.

Hernández, 63, denounced the sheriff’s methods.

“Mr. Arpaio arrives with his weapons and his police and everything. Who can stand against him? Why doesn’t he go where there are shootings?” she said.

“But he doesn’t look for criminals. What he looks for is innocent people.”

Listen to Hernández (in Spanish):

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

Several other families have been impacted by the raid, and some are left without their sole breadwinner.

“We’re very sad not just for us, but for everybody else that had someone arrested. There’s a woman with a four-month baby. Mr. Arpaio doesn’t stop to think … Who is going to take care of this woman or who is going to help her,” said Griselda, Sandra Figueroa’s sister, who asked that her last name not be published. “What is going to happen to all these families who have been abandoned?”

Griselda is worried about what could happen to her sister while in detention since she’s heard stories in the news about jailers abusing prisoners.

“What worries me is that they’re going to jail, they’re going to take them where there are many criminals and we don’t know what will happen to my sister and brother in law in there. They’re innocent, the only sin they committed is coming to this country to work.”

Listen to Griselda (in Spanish):

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

“He’s enforcing his own brand of law. … Can’t anyone do anything?” asked Andrés, Griselda’s husband.

Listen to Andrés (in Spanish):

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

The Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office is currently under investigation by the Department of Justice, and reportedly the FBI, for alleged civil rights violations and racial profiling.

As Arpaio vowed to continue cracking down on illegal immigration, human rights activists worried about a wave of laws making their way through the Arizona legislature that could further criminalize undocumented immigrants.

Dan Pochoda, lead attorney of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Arizona, said some of the bills might be challenged in court because immigration enforcement is the responsibility of the federal government. Yet the challenges are not always successful, as was the case with the state’s employer sanctions law.

A recent U.S. Supreme Court decision established that immigrant workers can’t be charged with identity theft if they did not knowingly steal the identification number they used to work. But this doesn’t impact Arizona, which has its own identity theft laws, Pochoda said.

Migrants charged with identity theft spend up to three months in detention if they choose to go to trial. Those who plead guilty are later turned over to federal immigration authorities.

Those who are deported with a felony –as would be the Figueroas’ case– don’t have a chance to adjust their immigration status in the future even if an immediate family member is a U.S. citizen.

Inside her aunt’s trailer, Katherine has built a little altar with pictures of her mother and father. She prays and hopes they’ll be released.

“Mom, I love you,” she wrote her in a letter. “I’ll do anything to get you out of there.”

Valeria Fernández is an independent journalist in Arizona.

    Tagged as: , , , , , , , , ,

    • Pingback: A Year After Arrest, Immigrant Family Marches Against SB 1070 | Feet in 2 Worlds · Immigration news · Immigration reform · Immigrant communities

    • Pingback: A Child of Undocumented Immigrants on Capitol Hill | Feet in 2 Worlds · Immigration news · Immigration reform · Immigrant communities

    • Roger Shoaf

      “They’re innocent, the only sin they committed is coming to this country to work.”

      Correct in part, illegal entry is a crime, but it is also a crime to commit perjury on the I9 form, and forgery to present phony papers as genuine.

      “‘Can’t anyone do anything?’ asked Andrés, Griselda’s husband”. Sure somebody can do something. If a person is in this country illegally they can return before they are picked up. That way no jail and no court hearings.

      Also I think that after the parents are deported, they can have their daughter sent back to them.

    • cynthia

      Wow,
      i cant even believe what some of you people are saying, i really dont understand how some people can be so ignorant. Immigrants have done nothing wrong they come here for a better life. Has everyone forgot that americans are immigrants too. You all were not born here, you stole the land from indians. So you should stop being hypocrites. Some of you say immigrants are taking all the jobs, well maybe immigrants are better for the job so they get the job. I also dont understand why they get arrested. Getting arrested for not being in the country you were born in , Really? Well i have news you, you didn’t make the earth so why are you making the rules. Especially those who say this story is dumb because how would you feel if you were a little 9 year old and you were riped apart from your parents ? Probably very alone and depressed I know I couldn’t live like that. Some of you people must really have not been raised well if you have these kinds of thoughts towarded people you don’t even know.Some people risk ther lifes for a better future and you dont even know there misery. Familys torn apart ,people in mexico dieing from hunger, and even getting in trouble for coming to this country for a better life .

      *COMMENT EDITED BY FI2W FOR LANGUAGE*

    • Edith

      To all those ignorant comments below me, didn’t we take this country from native americans. I strongly belief that you look at where your families come from before you start saying that illegal immigrants should be sent back to their own countries because at one point that is what we all where. This country would be nothing without them and if you disagree with that then go out there and work the jobs they do, you would not last a day. They come here for a better living and getting treated like dirt, but still look beyond that, you guys should almost praise them for having to deal with all that.

    • MysteryGirl

      For every insensitive jerk out there, please put yourself in their shoes. You have a family, in a country that is in the middle of a drug war, full of poverty. You are seeing your family starve and go without simple everyday necessities. Wouldn’t you go to the moon and back to help your family? Are you honestly telling me you wouldn’t do everything in your power to stop their suffering? “Oh honey, I’m going to just sit by and let you starve, because I’d rather not break the law than feed you”? Honestly people, I would do ANYTHING for my family. Many of you out there have kids. What would you do if you were in that situation. Would you rip your children away from the only life they know, living here, and take them to a place which is completely foreign to them? Their parents might be hispanic, from mexico etc, but the girl was born here. Her life is here, here identity and culture is here. My mom was an illegal immigrant. I’m an “anchor baby” as you all love to call us and I am definitely contributing more to society than stupid trailer trash, beer chugging, red necks out there. I’m going to college, paying for my education on my own. My mom left mexico at the age of 17 and came over so her family back home could have a comfortable life. Finally now, at the age of 42, she was finally granted her U.S citizenship. Ever since the day she got here, she has been reaching for that goal. It’s not an easy process, it’s a long road before you finally get it. You all think that that they’re here to take advantage of us, not pay taxes, etc etc. But every illegal immigrants goal is to get documented. That’s their goal. I spent most of my childhood living in fear. Going to school everyday, thinking about my mom the whole time. Praying that she would be there when I got back. I have all of you to thank. All those people who are against “my kind”. Because of you, my childhood consisted of fear. Because of you, I lay awake at night, praying to god to keep my mom with me. Because of you, I had to grow up faster than any child should. Go now. Go to your husbands, wives, lovers, children, families and hug them, tell them how much you love them, tell them how much you appreciate them being in your life. And as you do that, think of Katherine. Think that, because of you, she can’t do the same.

    • Geneva

      Thank you Mystery Girl
      I all of these people think you just go to the us embassy and say I want my papers today and they give you your documents. They think it is just like getting a passport. I myself am a us citizen born and raised here. I have been with my husband for 14 years his father brought him over as a child and applied for his papers and to this day we have not received them. it has been over 18 years. So in the real light who has broken the law. Everybody says that we cannot be charged with what our ancestors did i.e. with the slaves or the Native Americans. So why should the children be convicted and charged with what their parents crimes of trying to feed them. If the people really look at it they are taking the bread winners out of the home, and these children are going to foster care and then who really is paying the child’s bills. We are because they are in a state homes now. When you selfish people were not paying for anything for that child because they cannot get state help HELLO and then all of you think that they are taking your Social security away or depleting it. No they are not touching it all they are doing is putting into it because they will never claim it duh. Are all of you so stupid? And then you say that car wash was a young kid’s job most of the kids now will not even flip a hamburger they want mom and dad to pay for everything that is because you have taught your child to be that way. With your selfish views. AND FOR ALL OF THE WHITE PEOPLE OUT THERE THAT HAVE A PROBLEM WITH IMIGRATION WHERE DID YOU COME FROM. I KNOW YOUR GRANDPARENTS RAPED AND KILLED THE NATIVE AMERICANS AND SLAVES WHEN THEY CAME ACROSS DUH. PS I AM WHITE ALSO